Postponed from 2020, then from 2021, the Dance Reflections festival finally arrived in March 2022, with a packed fortnight of some 17 live works (one postponed to a month later), spread across Sadler’s Wells, the Royal Opera House and Tate Modern, plus four films streamed online. Programmed by Serge Laurent, former director of performance at the Pompidou Centre, and presented by the French luxury jewellery brand Van Cleef & Arpels, it came branded with class and quality – unusually, for the UK at least, linked to contemporary and experimental dance, quite a bit of it pretty challenging (I can’t imagine upmarket British brands venturing so boldly into such territory). With so many works on show, some of the festival’s richest rewards came in being able to track connections between different artists, styles and times.
The centrepiece of the opening night was Lyon Opera Ballet in Lucinda Childs’ now classic Dance (1979) – a point of departure for a particular trail that you could follow through the festival: minimalism. Dressed in celestial white, the dancers use a limited lexicon throughout – little more than step, hop, skip and jump – balletically styled, and performed without affect or affectation. In section one, they skim from side to side, then add diagonals. In section two, a soloist travels either in a straight line or in a circle. In section three, there are lines, circles, diagonals and squares. Around, in front and above them, a reshot version of Sol LeWitt’s original film of the work multiplies the dancing figures as well as their angle and scale. It’s all of a piece with Philip Glass’s music: steps, images, bodies and sounds refracted into cosmic harmonics that echo in the mind long after the performance is over. Simple, and sublime.
Watch Anne Teresa De Keersmaeker’s seminal Fase (1982), a four-part suite set to Steve Reich, and you recognise Dance as an inspiration, especially in the third section, Violin Phase, which echoes the Childs’s central solo. Built from elemental phrases – Childs’s on the ballet lexicon, De Keersmaeker’s on more matter-of-fact steps and swizzles – both trace a circular perimeter that in Childs is cut by a single line, in De Keersmaeker by radial spokes. The remaining three sections are duets, all determinedly repeating minimal phrases that coincide, overlap and separate as De Keersmaeker tenaciously pursues her compositional principles, and the dancers count rigorously. Where the Childs piece feels transcendental, Fase is more laden with worldly imagery: the contrast of feminine white dresses of the first and third sections counterpointing the tan masculine trousers of the second and fourth; the interrogation-room intensity of Come Out offsetting the carefree jogging of Clapping Music.
A signature work, Fase had until recently always featured De Keersmaeker herself. Here, her young dancers Laura Bachman and Soa Ratsifandrihana impart a punchier performance than I remember previously, even the deliberate swish of their skirts feeling less flirtatious than assertive. It’s exactly the same work, but they have made it their own.
In another loop back to Dance, Lucinda Childs’ niece Ruth presented four early works by her aunt from the 1970s – sparse, silent studies, evenly paced, in plain clothes. The solos Particular Reel (1973) and Katema (1978) foreshadow the solo from Dance in their clear pathways: a steady zigzag from one corner to another in Particular Reel, minimally embellished with steps and turns; a single diagonal for Katema in which Ruth Childs makes a series of additive forays to build up a chain of steps, spins, stretches and reverse-turns. Calico Mingling (1973) is a quartet based on a structured repetition of walking and arm-swinging, while Reclining Rondo (1975), another quartet, is a slow, synchronised sequence of lying and sitting poses.
These four pieces – Childs of the 70s, let’s call them – are studiously serious, so it’s quite a revelation to see a link between them and a traditional Italian polka, upbeat and spirited. The polka chinata (crouched polka) is danced by male pairs; to the basic polka steps as practised in the Bolognese filuzzi style of ballroom dancing they add the distinctive chinata move, whirling around each other in a low flywheel spin. The form had all but died out when it was stumbled upon by choreographer Alessandro Sciarroni, who used it for his 20-minute work Save the Last Dance for Me (2019), performed by polka chinata practitioners Gianmaria Borzillo and Giovanfrancesco Giannini.
What’s the link with Childs? At first it’s not at all obvious: the dancers are dressed in bright outfits, there’s music (a regular electro beat rather than the usual accordion), and the moves are the polka’s standard steps and turns. But they are choreographed in strict spatial paths: upright steps pacing a perimeter, crouched spins in the centre; furthermore, you soon notice that this dance – like much social dance – is built from an additive lexicon of steps that can be combined and recombined in various sequences. It’s a cumulative minimalist structure, expressed here not with seriousness but with pleasure and conviviality. It went down a treat.
Sciarroni’s larger work The Collection also uses social dance, music and choreographic minimalism, not to exhilarating but to deliberately exhausting effect. The piece is a version of his earlier FOLK-S adapted for the Lyon Opera Ballet, who perform it here. It is based on the thigh-slapping, foot-tapping Tyrolean Schuhplattler, each section starting with an appel in which the dancers set an introductory pulse, then perform sequences of Schuhplattler steps in strictly synchronised formations.
Every section follows this pattern, the main differences being in spacing and orientation, and in the one dramatic device that becomes increasingly clear over the work’s 80 minutes: in between sections, one dancer may leave, and the formation folk dancing will persist until there is only one person left standing – or, as the programme note ominously warns, “no more audience”. In other words: ad nauseum. Take that warning to heart, people.
There’s more exhaustively minimal repetition in Katerina Andreou’s 50-minute solo BSTRD (2018). Lights flare aggressively behind a raised platform where Andreou, determinedly casual in T-shirt, trousers and trainers, plays a record that hammers out nail-like beats in a rudimentary four-count rhythm. Part clubber, part folk dancer and always a slave to the rhythm, Andreou jogs, bops, bounces, jiggles and sidesteps, first straight-on, then side-on, then round the edges.
Differences seem to make no difference. She takes off her T-shirt; there’s an identical one beneath. She escapes from the platform, only to return and continue. She flips the record. The B-side bangs out the exact same rhythm. There is one big, irreversible change: the end. Andreou exits, leaving chalky clouds and soothing piano chords hanging in the air. The physical and mental relief is palpable.
Is it even right to use the same word, minimalism, for Dance, The Collection and BSTRD? The first uses repetition of minimal elements for compositional structure; the latter two, for physical and emotional effect – that is, not to build something up but to wear it out. It makes me wonder: what happened, culturally, between the Childs of the 70s, and now? (Discuss.)
Trisha Brown was an American contemporary of Lucinda Childs’, and like Childs (and indeed Merce Cunningham) she was well received and supported in France. At Tate Modern we saw two versions of her 1982 work Set and Reset. The first, a revival of the original, was performed by Rambert, who were a delight, and looked delighted. Laurie Anderson’s clanging, trolley-bell score rattles through the piece while above the stage, Robert Rauschenberg’s film projects bits of anything and everything: trains, offices, families, clouds, whatever. But the choreography is the star here, a casual yet thrilling texture of slipknot formations, full of off-the-cuff encounters, its timing as taut as it seems happenstance – high art conjured from happy accidents.
The second version was Candoco’s, called Set and Reset/Reset. It follows the same principles and is recognisably the same piece as the original, but now embodied by this mixed company of able-bodied and disabled dancers. The composition is such that rather than adapt the choreography to the performers, the performers can adapt themselves to the choreography. No matter whether they’re spinning a wheelchair, swinging a crutch or just extending an arm, it all just slots beautifully into place.
Set and Reset was created from a kind of choreographic seed: a single, set phrase of movement, which the dancers then improvised and reconfigured before it was re-set as the choreography. Anne Teresa De Keersmaeker has used a similar germinal phrase technique, notably in her masterful Drumming (1999) and Rain (2001). Her newly created Mystery Sonatas/For Rosa does it again, beginning with a female duet of almost painterly poses, followed by a freer, more floorbound solo. The work unfurls to the stately seventeenth-century music of Heinrich Biber, twice punctuated – bizarrely – by snippets of a country-and-western song. The source phrase imparts a flexible coherence to the numerous choreographic subsections, imprinted with some of De Keersmaeker’s stylistic signatures: spiralling systems, steps that follow musical cadences rather than written rhythms, walkers strolling among dancers as if they were just passing through. But at 135 ponderously paced minutes, it’s a drawn-out affair, and feels as if the real interest might lie in some unreachable subtext or context (the programme note makes much of the symbolism of roses and rosaries).
In Bombyx Mori (the scientific name for the silk moth), Ola Maciejewska took another American who was well received in France as her reference point: Loie Fuller, famous for transforming herself into apparitions of moving fabric and coloured light. Here, the costumes are inky black, and the three performers take an awful long time to lay them out and put them on (Fuller would surely have just got on with the show). Finally caped, the figures initially look sniggersomely comic: dressed-up brides of Dracula, po-facedly posing to avant-garde blips and squeaks. But a transformation does indeed take place: with the lights almost off, our senses readjust and we start to feel the spectral presence of owlish creatures, silken billows marking the beat of black wings. Fuller was called a “magician of light”; Maciejewska casts her spell in darkness.
Like Fuller, Maciejewska achieves her art more through stage effect than choreographic composition – the relative importance of which would make another route to track through the festival. Rather than follow it, let me instead mention two works which, in contrast to all the minimalist movement on show, went for maximal set, design, costume, sound and lighting, rather overwhelming the dance. Christian Rizzo’s Une Maison (2019) features a giant lattice of striplights, a pyramid of earth, animal-head masks, a phantom draped in white and a booming soundtrack – sensory stimulation masking the meandering choreography. Gisèle Vienne’s even more grandiloquent This Is How You Will Disappear (2010) stages rather than choreographs its performers: three characters cast adrift in a foggy forest that seems to breathe, glow and growl like a living creature, the noisome soundtrack of rumblings and scratches coming from its depths. Both works raise questions about how long stage effects can be sustained – and I mean that environmentally as well as dramaturgically.
I didn’t manage to catch the last double bill – When we speak I feel myself, Opening by Serafine1369 (aka Jamila Johnson-Small) and Infini by Boris Charmatz – nor the film programme, but two festival “outliers” deserve mention: Charmatz’s Somnole, a whimsical whistling solo in which he becomes a fleshy instrument of pipes and cavities, channelling spirits from the ether; and Neighbours, a terrific new duet by contemporary dancer Brigel Gjoka and b-boy Rauf “RubberLegz” Yasit that bridges minimal starkness and maximal stage effect, beginning with bare-bones choreography and ending with fleshed-out dance theatre.
Dance Reflections has been a bold and fascinating festival, though several of its big hitters were critical misses – in London at least. Does that say more about London, dance critics, French programming or the pieces themselves? I don’t know – but I think it’s a good question.
