There’s a moment in the cult TV series Buffy the Vampire Slayer when Buffy pummels her fists into the air to show a friend how she beat up a particularly annoying demon. Buffy reckons the demon got its just deserts, but her friend retorts: ‘Nobody deserves mime, Buffy.’
Ouch! Mime does indeed have a bad rep. Just mention the word and stock images spring unbidden to mind: figures in white facepaint and black gloves, archly opening invisible doors; the withering heights of Kate Bush’s early am-dram phase; and of course, those perilous moments in classical ballet where the dancing stops so that someone can explain something using mannered, incomprehensible gesticulations. Yes, it’s easy to make fun of mime – and people do. The all-male Ballets Trockadero de Monte Carlo, for example, milk mime for all it’s worth, and get laughs every time.
Yet mime is also a serious matter. The mute, stylised embodiment of utterance, action and emotion is a cornerstone of many performance traditions, from ballet to Japanese noh theatre, from classical Indian dance-drama to the uncanny aesthetics of puppetry, the visual storytelling of silent cinema, and the illusionist virtuosity of some hip-hop styles. Mime forms a vital seam in a whole range of performance techniques. To find out what mime looks like from the inside, rather than from sniggering distance, I spoke to a range of ballet practitioners: a dancer, a choreographer and two teachers.
First was Gary Avis, a principal character artist with the Royal Ballet whose on-Zoom persona was just as I had imagined: eager, unstarry, and incapable of talking without his hands leaping to life and waving about, as musical as a conductor’s. Avis has won the UK’s National Dance Award for best male classical performance not once, but twice (in 2012 and 2020) – a prize that generally goes to a principal dancer. On both occasions, he accepted the award with thanks for its recognition of character dancers – rarely the stars of the ballet world, yet integral to the artform.
‘I was interested in storytelling from a very young age,’ he tells me. ‘At first I wanted to be in musicals, and went to musical theatre college before the Royal Ballet School.’ There, he was inspired in particular by his mime and character teachers. ‘I saw how you could be a dancer and also tell imaginative, intricate stories through mime, and through a kind of body language.’
That idea of mime – to tell stories without words – became a focus in the eighteenth century, as ballet moved from court to theatre. In the nineteenth century, it is found both in the general idea of expressive gesture, and a more stylised code with specific meanings: love, death, marry, dance. This codified form fell out of use in newer choreography, but remains embedded in the classics – though many modern productions trim or adapt these mime sequences.
Expressive gesture and theatrical dancing, though, remain strong creative currents in ballet dancing and choreography. Indeed, as Avis talks, it becomes clear that he doesn’t make hard and fast distinctions between acting, mime and expression, or even dancing: underlying them all is a notion of body language. ‘It isn’t mime on one side or dance on the other. There’s a real crossover, now more than ever. Choreographers use mime in different ways to tell stories. Traditional ballet mime has more set gestures, but what’s interesting now is how mime morphs into more of a …’ – he searches for the word – ‘a physicality.’
Physicality, it seems to me, is the well that Avis taps – an inner impulse that finds its outlet in hugely different forms of expression: in the caperings of Dr Coppélius, the melodrama of Von Rothbart, MacMillan’s hot-headed Tybalt, or stolid Richard Dalloway in Wayne McGregor’s Woolf Works. How does he prepare for these roles?
‘I take the characters home with me,’ he says. ‘I’ve been caught many times pulling facial expressions on the train because I’m going through a piece of rep in my head!’ To understand the role, he says, ‘you need to know who your character is: where you’ve come from, why you’re in this situation, where you’re about to go.’ During performance too, he has words, dialogues, cues – a whole script that runs silently in his head but is ‘pronounced’, as he puts it, by his body.
Avis also watches people around him – on the train, in the street, on screen – and takes note of their mannerisms, interactions, ways of walking. Though he doesn’t understand sign language, he marvels at how people in the deaf community use it to converse. ‘It’s so expressive and so coded at the same time! Even if you don’t understand it, you sense the emotion, and the push and pull through the physical space of the dialogue. I try to get a sense of that energy when I’m performing. I like to feel that you could almost touch the words even though you can’t hear them.’
Choreographer Cathy Marston has, too, always been fascinated by storytelling and people-watching, and indeed has cast Avis in her ballets. But like most contemporary choreographers, she doesn’t use formal ballet mime, a gestural code which only the initiated understand. By way of illustration, she shows me the mime for ‘dance’ from Giselle – hands spiralling in a little vortex above her head, as if indicating a well-mannered cloud of gnats – and raises a quizzical eyebrow. Point taken.
Though she doesn’t use coded mime, Marston does use what you could call mimesis, or imitation – gesture, action and interaction – to build character and plot through movement. ‘A number of my ballets feature a cup of tea. It began with Ghosts in 2004, where I wanted that awkward feeling of people in the same room, but isolated – when you just hear swallowing and clinking and it’s all a bit louder than it should be.’ She used gestures from tea making and drinking not just to signal the story but to build character, mood and metaphor: emotions brewing, desires stirring. Like many modern choreographers, Marston tries to fuse choreography with acting and symbolism, without showing the seams.
Why have dancers with mime training, then? Not because they can perform ballet mime, but because of what lies behind that schooling. ‘Companies with a tradition of character dancing bring a level of acting into the choreography that is harder to get with more contemporary companies,’ she says. With Dangerous Liaisons (Royal Danish Ballet, 2017), for example, she recalls Sorella Englund – ‘nearly 80, fabulous, and with enormous respect through the whole company’ – as an emblem of how an acting style suffuses the whole company. San Francisco Ballet, with its far less theatrical repertoire, has a different culture. ‘When I first worked there I found it quite hard to draw the acting out. Whereas with the Royal or Royal Danish, the dancers can act big. It’s much easier to bring that down to the right level than to try to pull the acting out falsely.’
Ballet teacher Justine Berry is, without a doubt, the most enthusiastic champion of the character dancer I have met. Programme manager for the RAD Professional Teacher Diploma, and guest teacher for numerous major schools and companies, she began as a dancer with London City Ballet, and took on character roles from an exceptionally young age – Giselle’s mother, for example, when she was just 20. ‘I was very different to a lot of young dancers,’ she exclaims, happily. ‘I always found the mime just fascinating!’ When pushed, she thinks her favourite mime character would be the witch Madge in La Sylphide. ‘It’s so easy to go, she’s just this grumpy old person, but I would look at her and think: there’s so much in your life that we don’t know about.’ Good or bad, old or young, Berry always wants to know why a character is as they are. She is interested in the motivation behind the mime, a question that is foundational in theatre training; in ballet, much less so. For Berry, though, an understanding of motivation and backstory marks the difference between character and caricature. ‘If you just ham up the character, they don’t resonate with anyone. They become laughable.’
Berry insists on teaching mime to music. ‘Music is always central. When you’re teaching mime, it’s important to attach it to a musical phrase. In the rep, everything happens on the dynamic of the music – that’s how choreography and acting and setting and story all fit together.’
Berry also notices how mime can develop dancers as performers. ‘Mime roles need stage presence. It takes enormous confidence to carry the story and inhabit that character.’ Marston had mentioned this too: mime, and acting in general, can be intimidating – especially for younger dancers, who sometimes find their comfort zone within physical technique. Overcome those inhibitions, and you can hold a stage just by being on it.
That’s all well and good for people going into the profession – but what about the far greater number who take ballet classes but never make a vocation of it? Does mime serve any useful purpose for them? I put the question to Imogen Knight, a Trustee of the RAD and director of the Colours of Dance school in Cambridge, a largely non-vocational school that caters to lovers of dance rather than aspiring professionals.
Perhaps it’s that range of encounters that enables her to spell out what mime is. ‘In classical ballet,’ she says, ‘mime is a specialist discipline of its own, with its own code. Then you have these amazing mime artists in circus or theatre arts, with their own evolved disciplines that have nothing to do with ballet. And third, you have general storytelling, which is more like acting through movement. Underneath them all is the idea of non-verbal communication: how do I tell the story without words?’
Knight finds the coded ballet mime of most interest to adult students, who may already be balletgoers themselves. The RAD’s Discovering Repertoire programme is valuable here: mime becomes part of comprehending the art. For young children, Knight finds that storytelling comes into its own. ‘Older children perhaps are better at understanding abstracted moods that come from music or a way of moving, whereas at the junior levels you often get a stronger response if they have a storyline.’
Yet mime does play a part even at that young age. Take the reverence – a mimed ‘thank you’ that marks the beginning and end of every class. For Knight, this is no mere affectation, but a point of commonality that brings children together, both for each other and as a group. ‘It’s really simple,’ she says, ‘but it’s amazing how many parents burst into tears the first time they see it.’
There is something profound here, about being individuals and about belonging. In her RADiate classes – the RAD programme for children whose specific social, emotional or physical circumstances can make verbal communication challenging – Knight draws on that depth. Gestures become forms of recognition and validation. ‘Effectively you’re saying: how you communicate is good. Not different, not right: good. That is normalising for every child in the room.’ Communication through movement is not simply a code or message delivery system, but a form of sociality that humanises us, to ourselves and to each other. And everybody deserves that.
