Deaf Men Dancing, Letizia Mazzeo, The Federation

Signs without wonders, a choreographic whorl, and an entertainment-free downer


Sense of Freedom is a suite of dances by Mark Smith for his company of four deaf men. Song lyrics or spoken poetry are the choreographic starting points. Sign language or mime, directly referencing the source text, is variously elaborated, jazzed up and refracted across the group. The formation dancing and regular rhythms work well in the peppy opening number (to the Pet Shop Boys) and to the blokeish banter of the second section. But when the tone gets more serious (a poem about expression and sensation), it looks doggedly literal. The underlying idea is richly suggestive – choreography as a kind of physical song, with the body as both words and music – but these dances remain shackled to actual words and music; they need more sense of freedom.

Letizia Mazzeo’s solo Dahlia is a kind of choreographic whorl. At the centre sits Elsa Petit at a table; spiralling from it is a repeated mime sequence in which, like an odd fortune-telling ritual, she goes and gets a cuppa, lets the book fall open randomly and peers at the text revealed. The revelations, writ large on an overhead projector and accompanied by crashes of music, are baffling: the word “organ”, drops of water, the word “electrocardiogram”, each provoking cryptic solos by Petit. In the end, all these elements get jumbled, leaving Petit on the brink of stepping outside the system she’s set up. Dahlia is bewildering and fascinating in equal measure; uncanny too.

The Federation’s Encounters has the feel of an end-of-term revue at a stage school for girls: amusing for insiders, less so for everyone else. There are chorus lines of high-kicking showgirls, fembot formations, ironic jazz-hands numbers and send-ups of sexiness. Placards are held up, saying things like “is this contemporary dance?”, “I’ve seen better” and “can we have some applause…” (cue applause) “… for the critics?” (fade applause). My respective responses were “God I hope not, so have I and not from this one.”