Published by:

2011 issue 1, pp20-25
Publisher URL: http://www.rad.org.uk/more/dance-gazette

Simply the best?

Is dance a contest? How do young dancers psych themselves up for a competition?


Talking to this group of teenagers is making me feel like a loser. Well, they are ballet students, so what else would I expect? Compare us on criteria such as length of neck, uprightness of spine, tidiness of hair, freshness of face or degree of turnout (I’m talking overall presentation here, not just hip rotation), and there is simply no competition: they win hands down, legs up, every which way. But actually it is other, less tangible qualities that really get to me – focus, dedication, determination, grit – and I fear that on each measure I am frankly outclassed. Touchéd by teenagers, I think to myself glumly. And then I have to remind myself: I am not here to compete. They are.

The students are all semi-finalists in the Genée International Ballet Competition. Organised by the Royal Academy of Dance, this annual competition for non-professionals up to 19 years old is held in different cities around the world; in 2010, it was the turn of London. The 10 or so students that I’m talking to are mostly from Australia, and they’ve come here, like the nearly 80 other entrants, for a week’s preparation before the competition, during which time they take classes, get coaching sessions, learn a new solo commissioned from choreographer Liam Scarlett, and last but certainly not least, get to know each other.

It’s day three of the preparations, and I’m here at the RAD headquarters to get to know a little about them. There should be a collective noun for a group of ballet students. They are a class apart, with an entirely distinctive carriage and comportment. When I introduce myself, a row of heads, each perfectly poised atop an elongated neck, swivels in my direction and fixes me with bright, inquisitive eyes, like highly evolved meerkats. I plonk myself down like a somewhat amorphous lower life form, and ask them how they feel about competitions.

It turns out that many of them already have competition experience. Brooke Newman, 16, had entered Genée 2009 in Singapore, though she hadn’t got through to the finals. Why was she back for more? “I didn’t get past the semis,” she explains, “but I really enjoyed the competition, it was so friendly. I think that’s especially because of the preparation classes beforehand. In other competitions you don’t interact so much, but Genée has more of a feel of dance camp.”

So why not just go to dance camp? “For the exposure, for the experience,” replies Brooke. “It’s good to have coaching on that high level, with different teachers, learning new things. And it’s good to get out there, seeing the talent from all the other countries.”

Doesn’t the stress of a competition undermine the more feel-good benefits though? Not for these positive thinkers. Lachlan Monaghan, a 17-year-old Australian now at the Royal Ballet School, answers for the group. “Adrenaline and nerves can be good. If you’re a dancer, you’ll have that stress anyway. But you need a level of excitement to perform on stage: you just have to channel it. I kind of thrive on it.”

And what if you don’t? “That’s life. Learn.” It’s a blunt comeback that I find a little scary, but I’m beginning to expect this attitude from students: matter-of-fact, but a little unforgiving (most of all, I fear, of themselves). What happens if you have an off day? “Put it down to experience,” says Kurt Williams, 19. “And get over it.” He’s a sharp one. Perhaps I’m just envious that they seem to be made of sterner stuff than I am.

Of course there are also quite concrete benefits to competitions: prize money, publicity, and often scholarships to training schools. Sure, there are may tangible and intangible motives for participating in competitions, but isn’t the ultimate reason really just… to win? It’s a cat of a question that sets off a pigeon-flurry of laughter and looking among the students. (Sportspeople, I imagine, would have answered with a plain yes.) “No,” protests Brooke, backed by several of her classmates. “You come for the experience. Winning would of course be fantastic. But it’s an extra.”

“The journey is more important than the destination,” chips in Lachlan. “The process of learning is more important than getting to the top. As a dancer, you’re always learning: you never reach a final point.”

Perhaps that’s easier to say if you’ve already won a major competition, as Lachlan has (the 2009 the McDonald Performing Arts Challenge in Sydney). “Actually, wouldn’t we all like to win?” says Kurt, with a sardonic glance at his colleagues, setting off another flurry of laughter and looking around. But his point is well made. And it turns out that he knows the costs of striving too hard, having sustained a serious knee injury in a previous competition in 2008.

“I was performing my contemporary solo,” he remembers, “and I felt like someone had kicked me in the back of the knee. I came down, but pretended it was like the end pose – and then I almost crawled of the stage. I couldn’t stretch my knee at all, so I strapped it up for the next round of ballet improvisation, which I needed to do to qualify for the next section. But then I really had to stop, because I was hobbling. After the competition, I had to have reconstructive surgery on my knee: I had torn my anterior cruciate ligament in half. I was devastated.”

Kurt was down, but he was definitely not out. “The surgeon said he’d never seen someone recover so quickly. I was supposed to be out for 8 to 10 months, but I was back doing barre work after 4 months. It wasn’t being out of the competition that got to me: it was back at school, watching everyone else improving while I just sat and watched from the sidelines.”

And now, Kurt is back at another competition, with a new knee and a new mindset. “Looking back, I think I was building up to that injury. It was my first year of full-time training, and I was working really hard. I think the pressure was building and building, and finally it snapped. That happens.” He looks round, and the other students nod in recognition. And once again, I feel outclassed.

• • •

At 23, Liam Scarlett, who is choreographing the students’ solos for the Genée, is in an interesting position. As both a dancer and choreographer with the Royal Ballet, he is at a very different stage of his career than his students; but he is still young enough for his own experience as a competition student to be fresh in his memory.

“I did so many competitions,” he says, “but I never did well in them. I’m actually not a big fan of them. I sometimes just think that ballet is competitive enough already. Also, that some people get so involved with competitions, they lose sight of the dancing. The Genée has a good balance because it includes the preparation and coaching, the experience of working with a choreographer. You don’t just arrive with a set routine with your teacher, and stay in your bubble and just do it. Here, the students are interacting, getting to know people from different countries, different backgrounds. They’re nurtured as well. Sometimes you could even forget it’s a competition – which I think is the best possible thing. So it’s not all hype and hysteria and nervous wrecks running around for a week before the final.”

I watch Liam coach the girls’ class. The solo he has choreographed is not what I was expecting, and it reveals his underlying attitude towards dance competitions. It’s not at all flashy: there are no flourishes, no crowd-pleasing feats or judge-pleasing turns. It doesn’t even look that technically difficult. But it is very difficult, and very exposing: no one can get away with simply “executing” these steps. They need to overbalance, torque their shoulders, attend carefully to the musical phrasing. They need to think not just about what they’re doing, but why. And they need to have a degree of stage presence to carry it off. To perform it well is quite an achievement.

“I didn’t want to do a classroom style of piece,” explains Liam after the session. “This solo is designed to take the students right out of their comfort zone. It’s not just about technique, it’s about confidence, musicality and intelligence – all of which are just as important for a professional dancer.”

The solo pushes them personally too. “Yes,” agrees Liam. “They’re at a level when they’re crossing from childhood into adulthood, from student to professional. This solo isn’t for the classroom or the teacher – it’s for an audience. It’s not about getting all the steps right, with all the elements in place: it’s about joining up the handwriting, phrasing the dancing within the whole arc of the piece. To perform it you need to come into your own self. You have to recognise that this is not a group of students performing the same solo: this is you now.”

Is there a difference, I ask, between students who do well in competitions and those who do well as dancers? “Yes,” he replies. “There are competition winners and there are dancers. There is certainly an overlap, but they are not always the same people. And for myself, I’d always go for a dancer.”

• • •

Dance competitions have long been part of the dance world (the first Genée was held in 1931), but over the last decade or so they have gone mainstream, crossing into primetime television on shows such as Got to Dance and So You Think You Can Dance. And it hasn’t stopped there: dance numbers are now often to be seen alongside music and entertainment acts on general talent shows such as Britain’s Got Talent. They may be on a different platform, on a different scale and fulfil a different function, but these programmes have something fundamental in common with ballet competitions: in all of them, young dancers compete with each other to impress a panel of judges and the audience, with an eye on the prizes of fortune and fame.

One young dancer with considerable experience of competitions both on stage and on screen is Matthew Koon. Only just 17, and now a student at English National Ballet School, Matthew is most widely known from last year’s Got to Dance on Sky TV, where he came third; but he has also won a string of stage competitions, including the IDTA Senior Ballet Championship (2010), the International Ballet Championship and English Dance Awards (both 2009), and the Fonteyn Nureyev Young Dancers Competition (2008) – among others. Oh, and his professional experience is already impressive too: he made his professional debut playing the title role of the West End musical Billy Elliot, aged 12.

Needless to say, I am humbled by all these achievements; even more so when I actually speak to Matthew, who comes across as modest and amenable, feet firmly on the ground despite the heights he’s scaled. Matthew thinks that competitions have a very valuable role as a bridge between the worlds of school and stage. “Competitions can really help you prepare for a career in dance,” he says. “In training, you can easily turn inwards, but at a competition you have to perform for an audience. You have to combine technique with communication. You have to understand dance as an expressive art form.”

Communication with the audience was one of the big differences Matthew found between stage competitions and television talent shows. “With stage competitions,” he says, “you expect the judges and audiences to know about ballet or dance. With television, the audience is much broader. So Got to Dance really pushed me, because I had to think about what would communicate to people who don’t necessarily know anything about dance. And it made me see that the world is much bigger than the dance world.”

One thing he learned, for example, was that what looks good on stage doesn’t necessarily look good on a screen. “TV is a 2D image,” says Matthew. “That makes a big difference, and something that works well live doesn’t necessarily translate. At the same time, you can really play around with camera angles and do things you could never do on stage. It was lots of fun to learn about that.”

Was he disappointed that he didn’t win? Hardly. Like the Genée students, Matthew is a tenaciously positive thinker, who thinks that participation is its own reward and that setbacks should be learned from, even appreciated. “Winning a competition is of course a fantastic reward. But whether you win or get to the finals or don’t even get placed, you should take it as a learning experience. This career is going to be full of rejections and knockbacks, and it’s how you handle them that matters. Of course rejection is always hard. But I’d say that a dancer who has faced feelings of rejection as well as the joys of winning will be more fully rounded, as a person and as a performer.”

“A lot of competitions offer scholarships or contracts as prizes,” he continues, “so they can help launch you to the next step of your career. But they’re good also just because they get you out into the industry. And you never know who’s going to be watching and what they’ll be looking for.” In his own case, for example, direct outcomes of his appearance on Got to Dance included invitations to perform at gala and charity events, and a spell working for a record company on a music video.

“You never quite know what the result of a competition will be,” says Matthew. He pauses, then adds: “And you never quite know what you’ll get out of it either.”

• • •

His words ring in my mind at the finals of the Genée competition at Sadler’s Wells Theatre. Of the group that I spoke to, only Lachlan has made it to the Final (he gets a joint bronze). There were no gold medals awarded, but the winners – Sean Bates and Francesca Hayward – did, in my opinion as well as the judges’, deserve top place. At the reception after the show, Sean is elated but also (how do these ballet students do it?) grounded: he’s performed with a back injury and tonsillitis, he hasn’t pushed himself too hard, but still he slipped at the end of his classical solo. “It’s been worth it because of the whole week,” he says, “ with the classes and teachers and students. Yes, it could make a difference to my career. But a dancer who does well in competitions isn’t necessarily what a company director might want,” he adds, sagely. So what would a director want? “That,” he answers, “you never know.”

You never know. Matthew Koon had used the exact same words, and how apt they are. I, for example, was certain after watching Brooke Newman perform Liam Scarlett’s solo in class that I’d be seeing her in the Final (though I didn’t see her in the other categories). But she didn’t make it past the semis. I ask Liam about this and he says, “I am glad that Francesca won, it was well deserved. But Brooke was the first person I went up to tonight, and I said: you did that solo how I wanted it to be done, and I’m sorry you weren’t up there tonight. I hope that meant something to her.”

It did. She was clearly disappointed not to have got through to the finals, but she says that “the whole week has been absolutely fantastic. To have coaching from such highly qualified people, who all give you something different to take home. I loved Liam Scarlett’s solo – it was very different from anything you learn in class, and it was great to really put yourself into. So for him to recognise me as performing it how he would like it – well that was fantastic.”

It’s a curious thing about competitions: they are built on uncertainty. Without that fundamental element of doubt, the twin pistons of winning and losing would never spark into life, and you might as well hand out the prizes in advance. But uncertainty actually spreads much wider than the final scoreboard: you don’t even know what winning, losing, or even participating, might mean. It could be disappointment, or recognition by a choreographer, or injury, or a better understanding of yourself. In the end there’s only one certainty: that winning and losing in dance competitions are not the measure of success or failure in dance.