Holding Space is the kind of piece you don’t often see any more. It’s unshowy, experimental, idealistic, a little hit-and-miss – and utterly beguiling. Some of its principles – that everyday movement is valid choreographic material, that you don’t need to fit the dancer stereotype to perform a dance – have their roots in the eclectic career of its choreographer, Jacky Lansley. After dancing with the Royal Ballet, she changed direction to become a prime figure in the independent dance movement of the 1970s, and later a founding member of the X6 Collective, a radical group which set the agenda for British New Dance in the late 70s and early 80s. Her work has straddled the worlds of dance, film, theatre and performance art.
That diversity is reflected in Holding Space, which encompasses classroom steps, ordinary gestures and character acting, and brings together six diverse performers, ranging from 61-year-old Sandra Conley, a former Royal Ballet principal, to Lucy Tuck, with a background in musical theatre, and Gareth Farley, an actor. It is a measure of Lansley’s experience that this small gem of a piece coheres so well while effortlessly preserving its performers’ individuality.
Holding Space closely moulds its phrases to the music – movements from Schubert’s haunting late piano sonatas, played live by Philip Gammon. The opening episode is abstract, almost courtly. Formal steps and turns combine with simple gestures of hands and arms to make uncluttered phrases, repeated and varied in open patterns. It’s airy and spacious, made more so by the uncovered studio mirrors and the long twilight slanting through the skylight.
The adagio second section – no less formal but far more emotional – spirals around Conley and Tania Tempest-Hay, who seem like different ages of the same woman, or perhaps a mother with a grown-up daughter following in her footsteps. Tempest-Hay swirls and curves passionately, both leaning into and striking against her partner, Farley. Their older counterparts Conley and Fergus Early (another Royal Ballet and New Dance veteran) are more reticent on the surface but also seem more complex underneath – as if their bodies contain, rather than display, the depth of their experience. The two women echo each other’s moves, but only at the end of the section do they finally hold each other’s gaze, as if looking into mirror. What do they see in each other, in themselves? The question remains unanswered, but its implications flood the stage with thoughts and feelings about age and experience, about longing, recognition and regret.
The third section is in silence, but even here you can almost visualise a musical structure to the choreography, which sees Tempest-Hay and Robin Eun-ha Jung in a dancerly duet as the others don odd coats and hats, the theatrical trappings of character. And indeed the final section is more explicitly character-driven, the dancers ‘presenting’ themselves on stage before withdrawing in puzzlement, consulting books as if these could yield the answer to why they’re there. As throughout, the choreographic composition closely follows the musical one, its themes varied, recycled, counterposed and modulated. The effect is not to set the characters into a narrative, but to build layers and nuance to their presence – layers that are finally shrugged off again as the cast strip back to the plain white costumes they wore to begin with, melting back to their unadorned selves.
When they’re not participating in the central action, the dancers often simply walk around the edges of the studio, like passers-by. And perhaps that’s the key to this work’s enchantment: Holding Space seems to take some ordinary passers-by – a diverse group of people – and makes a dance from them, based on simple gestures and unprepossessing moves. But it’s the pattern, more than the substance, that beguiles, for just as Schubert’s music ‘holds’ the silence between its notes, so the choreography holds the spaces between the dancers – and it’s those gaps that tug at our imaginations.
It is also a satisfyingly layered work. It moves from a formal opening through to a more character-led close, but keeps a democratic sense of the performers’ differences all the way through. That it holds all these aspects in balance makes it a rich experience; that it is so unforced in achieving this makes it a pleasure.
