Who?
Jonathan Burrows, British choreographer and dancer, 41.
Jan Ritsema, Dutch theatre director, 56.
What?
Weak Dance Strong Questions
A minimalist movement piece
Stage: bare.
Sound: none.
Light: ordinary.
Clothes: also ordinary.
Where?
ICA, London.
When?
5–7 October 2001.
The two men wander about the stage. They circle each other, avoiding physical connection and scarcely making eye contact. Their movements are deliberately hesitant. Their steps falter, they snag on their own feet. Their elbows slip, undercutting each tentative gesture. Their joints give way, they trip over themselves. Each time they start moving in one direction, they hold back, or change direction. Sometimes they pat their own bodies distractedly, as if to check that they’re still there. They fumble momentarily with their own clothes. There is some absent-minded crotch and bum-scratching, but these – like all their other movements – are short-lived displacement activities, and the performers are equally uncommitted to them. Imagine watching a controlled experiment in which two chimps had been raised from birth in a sensory-deprivation tank, their aimless, uncertain motion the observable sign of their unstable senses of self, other and environment.
The piece deliberately avoids thematic or compositional development. After fifty minutes the performers walk off stage (they know when to stop because they can see the clock behind the audience). They return for their bow, and then again to take questions from the audience.
Why?
Burrows and Ritsema jettison the conventional trappings of staged dance – display, virtuosity and technique go out the window along with ambience, development and imagery – in order to reach a more neutral place. They have said that they were working to maintain a state of questioning and constant doubt as a way of being ‘free’. It sounds as if they were aiming for an almost empty existential state of non-commitment and non-attachment. But to do this in perfomance is a paradoxical strategy, like trying to represent a blank canvas by making marks on it. An almost Zen-like conundrum. Did we hear the sound of one hand clapping, or the sound of someone falling between two stools?
As with much conceptualist art, the work’s interest, its ‘strong questions’, are more provoked by the performance than raised within it. That point seemed tacitly acknowledged by holding a discussion after every show, the audience response and feedback becoming an integral part of the event. We too are part of this controlled experiment.
Burrows’ previous work was characterised by complex structures, articulate body movements, a rigorous sense of space and time. Here he seems to have reached a point where he needs to question his own practice and abandon acquired working habits in order to take stock before finding a way forward. Does Weak Dance Strong Questions throw his artistic baby out with his accumulated bathwater? The answer to that question depends less on the piece itself than on how he moves on from it.
